Just an experiment and analysis of the exact same prompt sent through the two versions the prompt will be

tell me an evocative real life ghost story

Chat GPT 3.5 Response

In the heart of a small, quaint town nestled deep within the misty mountains, there stood an old Victorian mansion known as Blackwood Manor. Legends whispered that the manor had a dark past, and locals claimed it was haunted by the spirit of a forlorn woman.

The tale began over a century ago when a young bride named Elizabeth resided in Blackwood Manor. She was married to a wealthy but cruel and possessive husband, Jonathan Blackwood. Trapped within the confines of the mansion’s opulent walls, Elizabeth yearned for freedom and true love.

One fateful night, as the moon cast an eerie glow upon the manor, Elizabeth made a desperate attempt to escape her torment. Clutching a small satchel filled with her treasured belongings, she slipped out of her room and crept through the dimly lit corridors.

But fate had different plans for Elizabeth. As she reached the grand staircase, a sudden gust of wind extinguished the candles, plunging her into darkness. In her panicked state, Elizabeth lost her footing and tumbled down the stairs, her neck snapping with a sickening crack.

Since that tragic night, the spirit of Elizabeth has been said to wander the halls of Blackwood Manor. Locals and visitors alike have reported encounters with a ghostly figure in a flowing white gown, her face etched with sorrow and longing.

Witnesses claim to have heard the echo of Elizabeth’s weeping and the haunting melody of a piano playing in the dead of night. Some even spoke of a chilling coldness that permeates the air when her presence is near.

Over the years, many have tried to uncover the truth behind Elizabeth’s death and bring peace to her restless spirit. Paranormal investigators, skeptics, and thrill-seekers have ventured into Blackwood Manor, armed with cameras, recorders, and their own courage.

But Elizabeth’s spirit remains elusive, slipping through their fingers like a wisp of smoke. Some believe she seeks justice, others think she yearns for companionship, still waiting for her true love to find her in the afterlife.

Regardless of the truth, the legend of Blackwood Manor continues to captivate the hearts and minds of those who dare to delve into the mysteries of the supernatural. It serves as a chilling reminder that some stories refuse to be forgotten, and the souls of the departed may forever linger in the realm of the living.

ChatGPT 4’s response

While AI cannot have personal experiences, I can certainly tell a tale that’s been passed down through generations, recorded as a real-life ghost story. One such story revolves around the famous Queen Mary ship, now a floating hotel, located in Long Beach, California.

Built in 1930, the RMS Queen Mary was the epitome of luxury for its time, serving as a transatlantic vessel for the wealthiest and most prestigious individuals. But when the Second World War hit, it was repurposed into the Grey Ghost, a transport ship for troops. Its glamorous interiors were stripped away to accommodate soldiers and essential supplies. Throughout the war, it’s said that the ship witnessed a lot of deaths, setting the stage for the ghostly encounters that would come to define it.

The most renowned tale is that of a young engineer named John Pedder. In 1966, during a routine drill, Pedder was crushed by a watertight door in the ship’s engine room, Door 13. His untimely death has led to numerous reported sightings of a young man in blue coveralls wandering the area. Many claim to have witnessed him, some even asserting that he disappeared before their eyes, leaving only a chilling presence and a cold spot.

The Queen’s Salon, once a bustling grand lounge, is now believed to be haunted by a ghost known as the “Lady in White”. She’s often seen dancing alone, still dressed in the elegant white gown she was wearing the night she allegedly died on the ship. The ship’s swimming pool, although no longer in use, is said to be home to several spirits, including those of children and a woman who drowned there.

While these accounts are compelling and chilling, they are anecdotal and have not been scientifically validated. Nonetheless, they serve as captivating tales that contribute to the allure of the RMS Queen Mary, making it a favorite among paranormal enthusiasts. Ghost or not, the Queen Mary stands as a relic of a bygone era, its rich history filled with tales of glamour, war, tragedy, and perhaps, the supernatural.

Here is a link to the conversation